A bill to include phosphate and potash on the Department of the Interior’s (DOI) final list of critical minerals for national security was introduced in the US House on June 13 by Reps. Kat Cammack (R-Fla.), Barry Moore (R-Ala.), Elissa Slotkin (D-Mich.), and Jimmy Panetta (D-Calif.). Sen. Thom Tillis (R-N.C.) is the lead sponsor of the legislation in the US Senate.
The sponsors said the bill seeks to spur domestic production of these minerals in an effort to reduce dependence on foreign sources, particularly as the ongoing war in Ukraine disrupts global supply chains and inflated fertilizer prices. Cammack, Moore, and Slotkin all serve on the House Agriculture Committee, while Panetta serves on the Ways and Means Subcommittee on Trade.
“A nation that cannot feed itself is not secure. Without the necessary inputs to feed, clothe, and fuel our nation, we’re leaving our food and national security up to our adversaries,” Cammack said. “Adding these vital resources to the Critical Minerals List will encourage increased domestic production and deliver much-needed relief to the Florida producers who rely on these inputs for their crops. We have the resources here at home; it’s time we tap into them.”
“America’s producers are the only customers who buy their inputs at retail cost and sell their outputs at wholesale price. Farmers, ranchers, and foresters in Alabama have been dealing with profit margins too thin to take care of their families,” said Moore. “Designating phosphate and potash as critical minerals is the first step in tapping our capacity for domestic production of our producers’ input costs, namely affordable fertilizer products.”
“Our food security is our national security, so when we’re dependent on Russian and Chinese minerals for the fertilizer that grows our crops, we are putting ourselves at risk,” said Slotkin.“Adding potash and phosphate to the Department of Interior’s Critical Minerals List will accurately reflect their strategic importance, encouraging increased domestic production, lowering fertilizer costs for our farmers, and keeping our food supply secure. And as one of the only states to hold its own supply of potash, Michigan is well-equipped to fuel a resurgence in production.”
The bill follows a DOI decision in 2021 to remove potash from the Critical Minerals List because its supply risk score fell just below the quantitative threshold (GM Nov. 24, 2021), even though potash had been added to the list in 2018 in response to Executive Order 13817, a federal strategy to ensure secure and reliable supplies of critical minerals.
A Federal Register notice on Nov. 9, 2021, said the production of potash – along with rhenium and strontium, two other minerals that did not make the list – was “either not highly concentrated or was concentrated in countries considered to be reliable trade partners,” despite acknowledging that the US was “highly net import reliant” for all three commodities. “Any changes in the supply chain dynamics of these commodities will be closely monitored, but none of the three is recommended for inclusion on the 2021 draft list of critical minerals,” the notice added.
Phosphates did not make it on the 2018 or 2021 lists. DOI said in 2021 that while it may be an essential mineral, the supply chain vulnerability for phosphates is mitigated by domestic production, lack of import dependence, and diverse, secure sources of supply.
“American producers are feeling the high prices for fertilizer due to the war in Ukraine and its disruption of the supply chains for needed minerals,” added Panetta. “We want to help our farmers with this bipartisan legislation that would allow the federal government to readily tap into our domestic potash and phosphate resources. Despite the devastation and destruction in Ukraine, we are acting in Congress to protect American agriculture and preserve global food security.”
Back in 2021, seven Republican Senators sent a letter to U.S. Geological Survey Acting Director Dave Applegate urging him not to remove potash from the Critical Minerals List and to add phosphates to the list, citing “a serious supply shortage” and a “doubling” of prices for both products (GM Dec. 17, 2021). Those senators included Roger Marshall (Kan.), John Boozman (Ark.), Chuck Grassley (Iowa), John Hoeven (N.D.), Mike Braun (Ind.), John Thune (S.D.), and Tommy Tuberville (Ala.).
At that time, phosphate, potash, and other fertilizer prices were rising rapidly amid supply chain disruptions, reaching a peak in spring 2022 following Russia’s invasion of Ukraine. Since then, however, fertilizer prices have been under steady pressure, with current NOLA DAP prices down nearly 43% and NOLA potash more than 48% below year-ago levels.