New players to pressure K market, says Fitch
London — Fitch Ratings Inc. is the latest to warn that new potash projects, especially low-cost Former Soviet Union projects, coming to the market in the next five years will lead to excess potash placing pressure on prices. The international ratings agency said July 21 the new projects will introduce new competitors vying for their place in the market. Fitch believes this will help keep prices down, which will in turn favor low-cost producers – such as Uralkali (currently rated by the ratings agency as BB+/Negative) and Belaruskali – and help them gain export market share. Like many analysts, it regards Potash Corp of Saskatchewan Inc.’s offer for K+S, whose Legacy project is expected to begin production in [late] 2016, as an attempt to maintain market share, production, and "therefore pricing influence in this increasingly competitive environment." Fitch warned K+S has high costs relative to many global peers, and the acquisition [should it occur] is therefore likely to affect PotashCorp.’s financial profile. "Maintaining strong customer relations will be crucial for higher-cost producers such as Mosaic (BBB/Stable), and to a certain degree PotashCorp., if they are to maintain market share," Fitch said. "But new projects should, however, enhance the credit profiles of Acron (BB-/Stable) and Eurochem (BB/Stable) as they become vertically integrated in potash," the ratings agency said. Fitch also expects Uralkali’s 55-60 percent EBITDA margins to be able to withstand large falls in potash prices. Fitch believes potash supply may outpace demand by around 8 percent in aggregate over the next five years. "Combined with high emerging market stock levels, this suggests continued low prices. Our forecast is for prices to remain at around US$300/mt [FOB], with further pressure towards US$280/mt [FOB] once new capacities come on stream," the ratings agency said. Fitch noted that excess supply over the next five to 10 years is being driven by EuroChem’s VolgaKaliy and Usolskiy potash projects, with an ultimate aggregate capacity of 8.3 million mt/y. Post 2020, Acron’s Verkhnekamsk Potash Co. (VPC) project (2.6 mt/y), as well as Uralkali’s new Solikamsk-2 mine (2.3 mt/y), are also expected to come online. "These projects are all lower down the potash cost curve than Canadian projects such as BHP Billiton’s (A+/Negative) Jansen project and K+S’ Legacy project, which are expected to have price floors of over US$300/mt in order to meet return on capital," Fitch said.