ICL CEO sees Rotem Amfert closure in 5 years; strike continues as parties talk
Israel Chemicals Ltd. (ICL) CEO Stefan Borgas has instructed the management of Rotem Amfert to prepare for the closure of the Rotem Amfert plant over the next five years. His instruction was given following a statement by Israel’s Health Minister Yael German that she was opposed to even a pilot plant for testing phosphate mining at the Sde Barir field near the town of Arad in southern Israel. The health minister said that after reading reports and comments by public health officials she concluded that even a pilot project would be wrong as it would give no assurances regarding full-scale mining operations.
German said she came to her decision after lengthy consultations with a U.S. environmental health expert hired by the ministry to make recommendations on whether to permit a pilot phosphate mining project near Arad. In his report Professor Jonathan Samet of the University of Southern California determined that a pilot would pose only a minimal increase in premature mortality among Arad residents. However, the report noted that a pilot would not provide sufficient results regarding the impact of full scale mining operations and whether this would harm the health of those exposed to airborne particles. German added that full-scale mining would expose the residents of the region to risks that do not meet the standards accepted in the U.S. and Europe.
The issue is now up to Interior Minister Gideon Saar to decide whether to recommend whether to proceed with a pilot plant. The Health Ministry does not have veto power over a final decision that could decide to give the go ahead. The Interior Ministry’s Planning Division is likely to rule on the controversial issue in the next few weeks.
ICL has warned in the past that without the Sde Barir field the company would have to close down its phosphate and fertilizer operations in Israel for lack of rock supplies, which are expected to be exhausted in 8 to 10 years. Borgas has instructed Rotem Amfert’s management to cease taking on any new workers, purchase of equipment and a halt to renovations of buildings and equipment. The shutdown of Rotem Amfert would entail the firing of 1,200 workers. Borgas said ICL would invest $500 to $600 million in a new mine at Sde Barir if the government approved mining operations there.
Meanwhile, the strike by Rotem Amfert workers over a planned reorganization plan and the firing of 127 workers by ICL is continuing. Contacts between the union and management resumed April 1. However, the latest instruction by Borgas is likely to further complicate the labor situation at the subsidiary, as well as at ICL.