The Agriculture Producers Association of Saskatchewan (APAS), Regina, is concerned that fertilizer prices across the border in the U.S. are lower and wants the provincial and federal governments to launch an investigation to find out what’s behind the “constant and currently unexplained price hikes and discrepancy between the Prairies and northern U.S. states.” According to APAS President Glenn Blakley, “A lot of the fertilizer that is being sold in the U.S. is coming from Canadian sources. Governments should be finding out why fertilizer companies can use Canadian natural resources to produce fertilizer and sell it cheaper to American farmers than to farmers in Canada. This is essentially providing a subsidy to American farmers at Canadian farmers’ expense, and governments have full responsibility to investigate and correct this situation on behalf of our producers.”
Blakley pointed to fertilizer prices that are increasing $200 to $300 per ton again this year, while at the same time prices are coming down for natural gas and input supply companies are experiencing record profits from these high prices. “Every increase in fertilizer prices is money that is coming out of farmers’ pockets,” he insisted. “Every $10 cost increase per ton takes $61 million from Canadian producers. If governments want to help farmers capitalize on higher grain prices and reinvest in their operations, they need to stop the predatory actions that happen every time we need to purchase inputs.”
Blakley said APAS is being joined by Keystone Ag Producers (KAP) and Wild Rose Agricultural Producers (WRAP) to put more pressure on government at both levels.
The Canadian Fertilizer Institute pointed out last week that the issue was addressed by the federal government last year, with a finding in March 2007 that there has been no significant difference in Canada-U.S. fertilizer prices in more than a decade. “The fertilizer market is global in nature and the North American fertilizer market is completely open and integrated,” according to Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada, a bi-weekly bulletin published March 30, 2007. “As a result, Canadian fertilizer prices are linked to the U.S. market. Statistical analysis has confirmed that average fertilizer prices in Canada and the U.S. border area were not statistically different for urea, mono-ammonium phosphate and muriate of potash over the 1993-2006 period.”
CFI noted the huge increase in international demand for fertilizer and tight supplies and said these influence the cost of fertilizer in Canada.
Furthermore, CFI said it was its understanding that the federal Bureau of Competition Policy has rejected calls by farm groups for an investigation. The Bureau had not returned calls at press time.