Israel’s Finance Ministry is stepping up its battle on royalties with Israel Chemicals Ltd. (ICL). The ministry’s accountant general has sent a letter to ICL demanding that the entire level of royalties issue be reopened. ICL reported on the letter in its annual report, issued in late March, but did not detail its contents, saying only that it was unclear at this stage how the issue would play out and what impact it would have on ICL profits.
In the letter, Accountant General Shuki Oren noted that the state has the right to demand a reopening of the level of royalties paid on the production in excess of 1 million mt of potash annually. Oren noted that the only stipulation was that the royalties should not exceed 10 percent of the value of the potash sales. He added that when the company was privatized in 1995, the government agreed not to reopen the issue prior to 2010.
The Finance Ministry said that the letter was in effect a demand for reopening the whole issue, and would specifically focus on production above 3 million mt annually. The ministry is proposing that the discussion be held as part of the arbitration between the Finance Ministry and ICL that relates to a demand for $291 million plus interest in royalties from 2000-2009. The arbitration is set to begin in the coming weeks.
Last month Israel’s Finance Ministry sued Dead Sea Works and its parent company, ICL, for back payment of the royalties (GM March 21, 2011). The Finance Ministry charges that DSW, a subsidiary of ICL, the country’s largest chemical concern, failed to transfer to the ministry all data pertaining to the mining operations of potash under the terms of the company’s concession. The ministry said that this prevented it from presenting the court with an exact amount in the suit, which pertains to royalties from 2000-2009.
In response, ICL said that it is studying the suit and is weighing its options, including presenting a countersuit against the government. ICL has denied any wrong doing and rejects claims that it owes the state money. The company said it has used the same accounting practices that were employed when ICL was state owned, and that were accepted by the Finance Ministry.
According to ICL, it transferred $20 million in royalties in 2007, $41 million in 2008, $90 million in 2009, and $23 million for 2010.